Loading
0 Chapters0 Books0 People0 Places
Jeremiah 41 — When the person who was supposed to be on your side wasn't
7 min read
fresh.bible editorialwas already gone. The — destroyed. The king — blinded and dragged to . The only thing holding the remaining survivors together was a governor named , a man had appointed to keep order among the people left behind. He was their last thread of stability in a world that had come completely undone.
Share this chapter
This chapter tells what happened when that thread was cut. And it happened over a meal.
was royalty — a descendant of the royal family, one of the former king's chief officers. He showed up at with ten men to visit . And Gedaliah, despite being warned about Ishmael's intentions in the previous chapter, welcomed him. They sat down together. Broke bread. And then:
While they were eating together at Mizpah, Ishmael and his ten men stood up and struck Gedaliah down with the sword — the man the king of Babylon had appointed as governor over the land. They killed him.
Ishmael also killed all the Judeans who were there with Gedaliah, along with the Babylonian soldiers stationed at Mizpah.
He killed him at the table. In the ancient world, sharing a meal with someone was a declaration of . It meant "you're safe with me." Ishmael used that trust as a weapon. This wasn't a battle. It was an execution disguised as . And the Babylonian soldiers who died alongside Gedaliah? That detail matters — because would eventually find out, and someone would have to answer for it.
What happened next is one of the most disturbing scenes in the entire book. The day after the murder — before word had spread — eighty men arrived from the north. They were mourners, coming from , , and with their beards shaved, their clothes torn, their bodies cut in grief. They were carrying and incense to present at the site of the Lord's .
These were devout, grieving men. And walked out to meet them:
Ishmael came out from Mizpah to meet them, weeping as he walked. When he reached them, he said, "Come — come in to Gedaliah."
But when they entered the city, Ishmael and his men slaughtered them and threw their bodies into a cistern.
He faked grief. He used their trust and their mourning to lure them inside the walls, and then he killed them. Seventy of the eighty, massacred. The only reason ten survived was because they bargained for their lives:
Ten of them said to Ishmael, "Don't kill us — we have hidden stores of wheat, barley, oil, and honey out in the fields." So he spared them.
The cistern where Ishmael dumped the bodies wasn't just any pit. It was a large cistern that King had dug generations earlier as a military defense. A structure built to protect people was now filled with their corpses. The text states it plainly: Ishmael filled it with the dead.
Let that sit. These eighty men came to . They were in mourning, carrying to God. And a man with tears on his face led them to their . There's something especially horrifying about violence that wears the face of compassion. It's the deepest kind of betrayal — not just of people, but of everything sacred.
With dead and the pilgrims massacred, still wasn't done. He rounded up everyone left in — the survivors had placed under Gedaliah's care:
Ishmael took captive all the remaining people in Mizpah — including the king's daughters and everyone the Babylonian captain of the guard had entrusted to Gedaliah. He gathered them all and set out toward the land of the Ammonites.
These were already . People who had survived the fall of , who had been placed under Gedaliah's protection specifically because they had nowhere else to go. Women, officials, ordinary people clinging to whatever was left. And now they were being marched east as hostages by a man who had just murdered their protector.
Every bit of stability they had was gone. In a matter of hours, the community that had started to rebuild was shattered. Sometimes the worst damage isn't done by the enemy outside the walls — it's done by the person who was supposed to be on your side.
But someone had been paying attention. — the same military leader who had tried to warn about plot — heard what happened. He gathered every fighting man he had and went after Ishmael.
When Johanan and all the military leaders with him heard about everything Ishmael had done, they mobilized all their men and went to confront him. They caught up with him at the great pool in Gibeon.
When the captives saw Johanan and his forces, they rejoiced. Every person Ishmael had taken from Mizpah turned around and ran to Johanan's side.
But Ishmael escaped with eight men and fled to the Ammonites.
There's a single word in this passage that carries the whole emotional weight: rejoiced. These hostages — who had just watched their governor murdered, who had been dragged away from their homes — saw Johanan's forces coming and they knew it was over. The relief must have been overwhelming.
But notice what also happened: Ishmael got away. He started with ten men, lost two somewhere along the way, and disappeared across the border. didn't come. Not yet. The man who murdered a governor, slaughtered mourners, and kidnapped a community walked free. That's a hard truth this chapter doesn't try to soften.
rescued the people. Soldiers, women, children, court officials — everyone had taken, Johanan brought back from . But what comes next isn't celebration. It's fear.
Johanan and the military leaders took the rescued survivors from Mizpah and traveled to Geruth Chimham, near Bethlehem. They intended to continue south into Egypt — because they were terrified of the Babylonians.
Ishmael had killed the governor Babylon appointed. And they knew Babylon would come looking for answers.
Think about where they were standing. — just miles from the ruins of . They could probably see the smoke damage from where they camped. Behind them was a shattered community and an unpunished murderer. Ahead of them was — the very place God had repeatedly told not to run to.
They hadn't done anything wrong. Johanan had tried to stop this. He'd warned . He'd rescued the captives. And yet here he was, afraid that would hold everyone accountable for what one violent man had done. Fear doesn't always care about fairness. Sometimes the people who did the right thing still end up running.
This chapter ends without resolution. No prophetic word. No divine intervention. Just a group of survivors huddled near Bethlehem, trying to decide whether to flee to Egypt or stay and face whatever comes. The next chapter will reveal what God says through . But for now — just the silence, the fear, and a road stretching south.